Here I am fixing to rant about something a client told me today. She had a weigh-in and “only” lost .4lbs. Being a Phit-N-Phat girl she knew that she had:
1. lost fat and not muscle
2. made great choices all week with food
3. exercised like a queen
She was a little disappointed. It’s easy to be being a woman in a society where the stupid scale is the #1 indicator of success. I totally understand the want and need for big numbers. BUT, what infuriates me is how her weigh-in person handled the situation. Rather than looking at her food journal and seeing that she is doing all the things you need to do to lead a healthy lifestyle, this fool tells her…
“Well, honey, it doesn’t matter if you are building muscle or losing weight …. a pound is a pound so if you are overweight by 50 lbs then you are overweight.”
Say what? This is wrong on so many levels I can hardly see straight enough to type this message.
1. So you think a pound of fat and a pound of muscle are the same? I tell you what, I’ll take weighing 133 pounds and wearing a 4/6 over weighing 125 pounds and wearing a 8/10 any damn day of the week.
2. I dare a Skinny Fat to go head to head with my girls who still have 30, 40, and 50 pounds to lose. In fact, my girls eat right and exercise so hard (post if you are one of them) that I would put my money on them against a Skinny Fat doing the same routine any day. Case in point, my girl Amber (you go girl) is nuts in the gym and she has an undisclosed amount of weight to lose. She can squat and lunge circles around half of the Skinny Fats I know.
3. This fool lady discounted a whole week of hard work, determination, and sweat my girl put in the gym. Skinny Fat does this all in the name of the scale not moving as fast as she thinks it should. Maybe she needs to come to PNP and look over some of my blogs about the scale.
Argh! Ladies (and gents), here’s the last paragraph of MY email to my girl to help her see the real deal and not the old school dribble she heard from Skinny Fat today…
As long as you are working hard and eating right it will all take care of itself in the end…it might not be on your timetable and it might not be instant gratification each week, but it will happen. You just can’t let the scale and that blowhard get into your mind. Stay strong and focused on the task at hand. Be proud of all that you accomplished with eating right and exercising. That stuff is a whole lot more important because it produces results. I know you, XXX, and you wouldn’t be a part of my team if you were not in this for the long haul. We are all part of this because we want a better, fitter life for ourselves and not a quickie fix that doesn’t last a lifetime.
I then told her to stay strong and eat a piece of grilled chicken tonight.
______________________
Today’s Workout: Shoulders
Superset One: 3 sets
Lateral Raise
Overhead Presses
Push Ups and then Leg In and Outs during the rest period
Superset Two: 3 sets
Seated Rear Delts
Upright Rows
Close Grip Push Ups then hand to ceiling crunches during the rest period
SS Three: 3 sets
Plate Raises to front (I finally went up in weight today Woohoo!)
Weighted Roman Twists
High Cable Pulls
Cardio: A Test Run of an Elliptical Routine for 30 minutes that is leg heavy.
Interval Style consisting of Side Shuffles, Ali Twists, Walking Squats, Walking Lunges, Bench Squats weighted, and High Knee Runs. It will eventually be a HIIT Routine with 5 min. warm up and 5 min. cool down and 20 minutes of loaded work. Sort of like the routine from two days ago except the intervals will be low enough intensity to do for a full minute.
Daily Food Journal:
B – 1 cup of Fiber One with 1/4 frozen cherries, and 1/2 cup of skim, 1 hard boiled egg
S – EAS Shake and a banana
L – Tofu Grills Hickory Flavor, green beans, sweet potato
S – 1.5 cups of fresh fruit
S – 2 cups of lite popcorn and 2 slices of organic beef jerky
D – Thai Tuna on lettuce and snap peas
S – Fage Yogurt with SF Jelly and Splenda





I must admit that I am one of your girls and I have to tell myself that it is not the number on the scale that shows my progress.I know I am healthier than I was a month ago. I may not be much lighter but my eating is 100% better,I am building muscle and I have more energy.I do not weigh in at meetings anymore for this reason alone.I fell defeated if the numbers are not big enough.
Comment by monica — May 9, 2007 @ 9:24 pm
Thanks for the post here Corinne. I am on of your girls, I have been doing this for about 3 1/2 weeks and I am already feeling stronger, healthier than a lot of these other gals (most days).
I will take on this weigh in gal in exercise and see how many lunges she can do and then how many I can do. Sure I might not be able to walk tomorrow but that moment I will shine on!!!
Comment by Becca — May 9, 2007 @ 9:34 pm
I am a Proud Phattie and feeling much stronger despite a small loss in weight over the last five weeks (but I’ve lost more inches then pounds). I’m working on adjusting my thinking away from the scale and looking at the big picture.
Comment by Paula — May 9, 2007 @ 10:08 pm
OMG, firstly how rude on the part of the WW individual. The person who had this experience should call and complain.
Secondly, I can relate to this 100%, Corinne and I had this conversation yesterday. My WW is tonight and I’m worried about the number but I know when I’m burning 777 cals in a 1.5 hour workout that I CANNOT be gaining weight or FAT weight. It is muscle, or water retention. To me it is slow and steady wins the race. My PNP workouts are harder than what some of them men do at my gym and trust me they notice.
Comment by Kathleen — May 10, 2007 @ 6:13 am
Some people can be so rude and negative. Ignore her and listen to someone who has succeeded in her own quest to lose weight (Corrine)! I know Corrine and she knows her stuff. I’ve been working out for about 15 years and she has shown me things over this past year that has helped me build a leaner harder body! THANKS
Comment by Lisa — May 10, 2007 @ 9:09 am
This is soooooo bad. I can not believe after all the WW sessions I sat in the last year and half where we talked about the importance of exercise, muscle weight being more compact than the same amount of fat etc. that there is somebody out there leading meetings that still doesn’t “get it”. I hope the person will complain becasue that leader needs to go back to Weight Loss 101 with a good dose of Remedial Coaching Skills.
Yes a pound = a pound, but they are far from the same thing on/in the body.
Please write a letter to WW, they need to hear about this so this person does not drive off other people.
Comment by kerry — May 10, 2007 @ 9:11 am
I am a PNP girl and can tell you in the 2 months I’ve been working w/Corinne, I haven’t dropped much on the scale but have lost an overall 9 inches from my body. ’nuff said.
Comment by Lisa — May 10, 2007 @ 9:43 am
Phat Trish checking in. I am so IRRITATED at the IGNORANCE of that check in person. I am proud to say I will shortly be GAINING – that’s right – GAINING weight to add muscle. Because I am building a healthy, strong body – not a skinny fat one!!
I think that check in lady is a skinny fat head!!! (I’m so mature!!)
Comment by Trish — May 10, 2007 @ 10:05 am
I’m so glad you guys spoke up. It’s unfortunate someone would be so uninformed and given the responsibility of weighing people in. Sigh…WW does so much good for so many people, but they really need to keep some quality control over the things their employees are saying.
Comment by phitnphat — May 10, 2007 @ 10:59 am
I have been dealing with my own WW battle… currently a meetings goer and honestly spend most of my meeting wanting to injure people for comments just like that. Never mind the topic of snacks… if one more person says they don’t exercise and eat 100 calorie packs for all their snacks followed by “and I lost 3lbs this week!” I will probably thow up.
Thank you Corinne, for posting this. I really needed to see it today.
You have to know that you are making the right long term changes for your body and that slow and steady is the way to go.
Comment by fitme2006 — May 10, 2007 @ 11:40 am
This is so infuriating! One of you Phatties checking in (I know, so late), but I can’t believe this person whose just so uninformed.
Let me just say that I was about 20 lbs more than I did the last time I was wearing the size that I am wearing now, and I look better than I have in YEARS!
I am so glad to have you Corinne because I think most people would think I was crazy when I added more points to my regimen to keep from losing TOO much weight in a week. We gotta save/protect those muscles!
Comment by Rho — May 10, 2007 @ 7:59 pm
I too, battle with that scale every week. As a lifetimer at WW for 2 yrs now and weight training on my own, I know how it feels to see the scale go up when I know I’ve eaten great and exercised. It’s only water retention but it is still hard to see those numbers. That check-in lady is totally uninformed and unfortunately it’s hurting people! Thanks for this post Corinne! I needed this!
Comment by Jennifer (jls1339) — May 11, 2007 @ 5:16 am
I love the skinny fat analogy- I will never be a very skinny person no matter what I do – but I just ran a 5 k in under 36 minutes after 5 months of training and I know tons of people way skinnier then me who can’t do that.
Comment by Jen — May 14, 2007 @ 8:29 am